Archive for the ‘ Negative being ’ Category

A Society That is Determined Not to Work

Perhaps you have not noticed this – but it is one of the defining features of our times – our Dysfunctional Times. It just doesn’t work – and we are determined to keep it that way. And even more strangely, we are determined to not notice that we are this way.

This is shameful behavior, and we ought to be ashamed of ourselves. But we are not – we are pleased with ourselves instead. As if we had some great accomplishment to brag about.

I am tempted to philosophize here, and speak of our discovery of negative being or perhaps negative reality. We have discovered that we could move in an entirely new direction – one that will result in our total destruction. But instead of horrifying us – this attracts us.

We should rewrite our history to show how this fundamental transformation took place. This hasn’t been done before because this possibility never occurred to us – it was too shocking to even be considered. But now it has happened, we need to backtrack and take it seriously.

We can easily answer the question which bedevils us “Why aren’t things working?” The answer is “Because we don’t want them to work!”

We have gone into a self-destruct mode without realizing it – because the first thing we destroyed was our selves – our self-awareness.

You may object – as I did myself – that we have been able to make some things work. New software comes out all time time – Windows 8, for example. But this only happens in an environment that is determined to not make things work overall.

I speak from experience here. I worked in the software industry for ten years – and I watched these software companies self-destruct over and over. And noticed how no one was noticing this. They were not only destroying themselves, they were destroying all the people associated with them – their employees, investors, and customers.

There I was, the solitary observer at the end of an era, noticing what everyone else was incapable of noticing. And wondering why. I am reminded of the Stoic Philosophers at the end of the Roman Empire. And it seems to me our situation is similar.

And this is not a bad analogy. It is one we could use to our advantage. The Roman Empire was over-developed – as our own is. We only need to ask ourselves “What is the over-development in our own time?”

Two thousand years ago, this would have been obvious from looking at a map of the Empire. It was physically over-extended – it covered far more territory than it could defend. But accurate maps would not appear until much later – after the Empire was long gone.

What kind of map can we provide for our own time? I think we need to start from where we are – with an honest evaluation of where we are – completely messed up. And go from there.

We have made some assumptions – just as the Romans did – that didn’t work. One of them was that perpetual exponential economic growth had to happen – or more correctly, had to continue to happen. It doesn’t take much thought to realize this is not possible.

But Americans do not think; they just insist it has to happen anyway. Their business plan cannot possibly work – but they are determined to make it work anyway.

The Attractiveness of Negative Being

Being is hard to understand – but easy enough to do. Even a rock can do it. And earthworms can do it even better. Only people have trouble with it. And we have succeeded in messing it up entirely. How come?

Frankly, I do not know – but I am willing to at least ask the question. And a properly formulated question is the biggest part of solving a problem. And for humans our biggest problem is that of being.

And right here is where I lose all my readers – who are not interested in thinking at all. This is quite a contrast to the Age of Reason – when we (or at least our best and brightest) loved to think – and write about their thinking. What has happened to us?

Here again, I have no idea – I can only say that something happened, and it was not nice. But it had something to do with the attractiveness of negative being. What on earth do I mean by that?

People have the amazing capability to reproduce reality in themselves. Any living being can do this – it is aware of its environment, and can respond to it appropriately. Any species that makes inappropriate responses doesn’t last long.

People, with their highly-developed central nervous system – some would say over-developed central nervous system – can easily go crazy - in any number of ways. One of these is to go negative - and destroy themselves.

This has happened many times. History is full of examples of people who rose and fell. There have been all kinds of rational explanations of this. My explanation involves the attractiveness of negative being – a concept only people could possibly have.

Concept is probably the wrong word. It seems to be more of a gut-level social impulse. I am listening to The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich - which tries to answer the question (which as been asked over and over)  ”Why were the Germans so crazy?”

The same question could be asked of Americans in the last half of last century “Why were they so crazy?”

My answer is that, for complicated reasons we do not understand – people find negative being very attractive. And they find leaders that help them to destroy themselves.

Since we now have a global culture – this destruction is global. Leadership is no longer necessary – the people can do it all by themselves.

You want a solution? Simply convince people that they are going this route. That’s all.

A Reality Better than Real

This posting is about social insanity – a common situation that has never gotten the attention it deserves. It is so common, I suspect it is normal – as religion is normal.

An outline is easy enough. People and groups develop alternative realities of their own. These can operate in two different ways – to enhance Reality (with a capital R) or destroy it. In the last two hundred years or so, the destructive variety has predominated.

This happens as a result of a feedback mechanism, something common in all complex situations. The result is a reversal of values. Good becomes Bad, and Bad becomes Good. This can happen very easily, because our minds perceive opposites as being identical. And we can end up valuing behavior that would never permit in our right minds.

We end up destroying ourselves – and greatly enjoy doing this.

Group insanity operates differently from individual insanity. I speak from experience here. My ex suffered from schizophrenia, and the last time I saw here I was never so shocked in my life. She had wasted away into a shadowy ghost - and not too much later, killed herself. I could not imagine how much she suffered. But did she experience suffering herself? I wonder.

Our subjective emotions can be far different from our objective ones. In fact, this is where our language breaks down, and doesn’t allow us to speak of this very important fact – that what we seem to be feeling is not what (at a different level) we are actually  feeling.

And, in contrast to what I originally assumed, this works the same for individual insanity and group insanity. Groups can also be out of touch with their actual feelings. Bear with me while I think this out.

What I seem to be talking about are the conscious and unconscious minds – and for groups, the collective unconscious. Our conscious minds are controlled by our unconscious minds – not the other way around, as we assumed in the Age of Reason.

This makes it imperative that we understand our unconscious – both our individual and our collective. How to do this?

First of all, we have to acknowledge that our unconsciouses (the plural form of unconscious) do exist. We have lost this awareness – which means we have lost most of our awareness about ourselves, individually and collectively. The worst thing that could possibly have happened to us – has happened.

We did this with the best of intentions – to avoid the pain of realizing where we were. But the result (as is often the case with any avoidant behavior, which is what most of our addictions amount to) was disastrous. We lost touch with Reality.

Does this mean we are doomed? No, all we have to do is back up in time (using our conscious minds) and feel what happened to us, and why we acted as we did. Note that I did not say we had to think about this, but feel about it – pay careful attention to our emotions (which are most of what we are).

This is not such a strange activity – we have been doing it for thousands of years. This is what the arts are – an exploration of our (mostly unconscious) selves. This is the place to refer to an article in the NY Times Philosophy and the Poetic Imagination. This is also why we have lost our interest in Poetry – because it makes us feel too much. Instead, we have ended up not feeling anything – dead.

I am listening to HitlerLand – yet another book about Nazism. But this has a different approach – how American journalists experienced the rise of Hitler. This back when the newspapers and the wire services supported many such journalists. And the Public was eager to read what they said. Quite a contrast to today – when none of this is true.

One thing they all agreed on was that Nazism was group insanity. One of many that was sweeping the world back in the Thirties. These are often collectively referred to a Fascism – but this ignores parallel developments in the Soviet Union, Japan, and China.  And even Cambodia. The whole world went crazy destructive – and the result was WWII.

What happened after WWII (which was well-documented) was something that happened under the radar screen - massive self-destruction – which we seem determined to ignore.

A massive social breakdown occurred about 1980 (with the end of the Sixties) – and interestingly enough, with the coming of the Computer. This is often called Globalization – and is something I intend to pursue. Stay tuned.

The Mythology of High-Tech

I have always thought of a myth as some kind of fairy tale. Charming and insightful perhaps, but having little relevance to modern life.

But I understood nothing about mythology. Every culture has had its own myths and these myths explained how those people understood their world. And we are no different.

This immediately raises the question “What about a culture that understands nothing about its world, and doesn’t want to?” Referring to our culture, of course, with its inverted values – where nothing is everything. How could we possibly have any myths?

The answer hits me right in the face “The belief that we have no myths is a myth itself.” In point of fact, we have a powerful mythology – and it runs our lives.

Lewis Mumford made just this point in his huge The Myth of the Machine – but his coverage of high-tech was inadequate – and I could not take on that job then. I can now.

Neil Postman was a big help, when he followed up on McLuhan with his book Amusing Ourselves to Death; public discourse in the age of show business – where he does an excellent job of exposing the insidious effects of Television. Insights which were totally ignored by the TV-viewing public.

The reason for this was simple, and shocking (at least for me) people have ceased to exist! And they cannot be expected to know anything.

If I have a key insight, it is this. And I can flatter myself by noting that no one is interested in it. But I am getting off the subject.

Neil Postman has done a good job of describing the impact of TV – but I was shocked to find that he knew nothing about the impact of the Computer!

I do, because I was forced to live in the high-tech world for all of my working life. And I can summarize it easily – it is horrible! In fact, horrible is too inadequate a word. There is no word, or combination of words, that can express it. Although poets, and other artists, have been hard at work on it for a century. With the same result – the public has ignored them – or if they had a job, made them unemployable (the modern equivalent of death).

By extreme good luck, I ended up in Costa Rica, living on my Social Security. Otherwise, I would have shot myself. When I see all the people I left behind, and all their follies, I have to remind myself that they are only trying to stay alive – even if that means killing themselves to do this.

This could be a summary of the impact of the computer – it finishes the job started by Television: the destruction of the human race!

Just as I know the problem, I also know its solution, which is simple – we have to understand the computer, and how it works. And by that I mean the whole hardware, software, Internet, wireless complex.

You might ask “What about all the computer specialists who do understand it? They know as little about the State of the World as anyone else!” A very good point. The people who have to do the understanding are ordinary people who are taking a look under the sheets at all the strange things going on there.

But we are forbidden to do this! If we understood this powerful mythology, or religion, only a little bit – it would lose its power over us. Which depends entirely on its being regarded as beyond our understanding.

Awful People

Perhaps it takes one to know one. I can hardly qualify for the world’s worst person, but perhaps I qualify as a normal run-of-the-mill one. And one, who knowing it well, is disgusted by it.

I like the Merriam-Webster definition for run-of-the-mill: manufactured goods not graded or sorted for quality. I have definitely been manufactured – as we all have been. And this manufacturing process had not been beneficial. It has produced, in my opinion, the worst kind of people. But people with a very high opinion of themselves.

Ortega y Gasset – a philosopher much admired, but totally ignored – saw much the same thing in the mass.  Mass production, the technology of the Industrial Revolution, also produced mass man. And the world has never recovered from this.

If we had been smart, which we certainly were not, we would have carefully considered the effects of each of our new technologies (beginning with the Printing Press) before making them part of us. Only now, with people like McLuhan, have we done this – but these thinkers have been ignored too.

We are standing in the remains of a battlefield, surrounded by total destruction, saying “Maybe we shouldn’t have done this.” But everyone else is saying “We had to do it, we didn’t have much choice.”

And they are right: they had been changed so that they had no choice.

They had become awful (or self-destructive) people.

Nothing Cannot be Destroyed

But nothing can destroy anything – and is actively doing so. This can be rephrased as: nobodies cannot be destroyed, but they can destroy anyone or anything – and are actively doing so.

It is important to emphasis the negative – not the positive, since that has been done too much already, and is largely responsible for getting us into this mess.

The metaphor that best illustrates our society is that of a black hole – something only we could have imagined. Perhaps other intelligent beings are now marveling at our ongoing social collapse – and hopefully deriving lessons from it.

It is important to be aware of the emotions behind this development – because they are the fuel that is driving it. People are doing this because it feels good. Because it makes them feel powerful.

People have always motivated by two forces: the desire to build and the desire to destroy – construction and destruction. We had to be good at construction, because we went from being apes to being something truly amazing: human beings.

But for reasons I can only guess at, we have done an about-face, and are destroying the work of millions of years in only a few hundred.  The reasons are not important, however, only the end-result.

All we have to do is recognize that – but this is impossible.

Now that I have written this, I am amazed by it – and not sure what to do next. I seem to be a voice crying in the wilderness – to quote the Good Book. But one who is also having some excellent coffee for breakfast - definitely an improvement.

I have noticed that as I have been making my latest discoveries that I am suffering from vertigo, or severe disorientation. Not a pleasant feeling, believe me. My body has lost its bearings, and I have to move carefully to keep from falling down.

This has happened to me before. Once, I was backpacking and hiking beyond the trailhead, in beautiful mountain country, I was listening to a tape about The Father Wound. The speaker was saying that people are often aware of their Mother Wounds, and are working on them, but they are unaware of their Father Wounds.This made sense, and I began to wonder about my own – and be vaguely aware that I had some. My father had disappointed me, I knew.

When I woke up next morning in my little tent, I was so dizzy I could not get out of my sleeping bag. I thought I was going to die out there and be eaten by the coyotes. This made me do some hard thinking, and I discovered I had to stop all thinking. I had been obsessing about my Father Wounds, and my body could not handle this.

I managed to get to my feet, pack up and walk out. A doctor thought I had an ear infection, and give me pills that only make it worse. I knew I had to get back into therapy again, and fix what was wrong with me.

Finding a therapist was no problem, Silicon Valley is full of them. People need them desperately, and have the money to pay for them. I had a bunch of them. Did they help? Not really. But looking back at it, they helped me to survive the High-Tech world, by getting out of it, and building a new life in Costa Rica. I got one valuable message from them  ”Yes, you do exist, and you are not all that terrible.”

Will this move to another culture work for anyone else? Probably not. All kinds of people come down in search of a new life – and they usually fail. This is a huge job, and they are not prepared for it.

I just saw a tourist bus yesterday, that stopped to let its passengers take a picture of themselves in from of our historic church. I was gawking at them, and they were gawking at me. The bus continued on see the rest of the sights of our scenic valley – and then went back to civilization again. The tourists were no doubt satisfied with their day-trip – but could not see why anyone would want to live here, in such primitive conditions.

They do not know that Orosi has fast Internet connections. And that anything you want can be flown in from Miami to the nearest large town, less than an hour’s bus ride away. They only want to be surrounded by good stuff – not by what appears to them to be poverty.

I want to finish off with one observation. That our collapse, our social implosion, has coincided with a technical explosion. Perhaps we are so infatuated with our things we consider our selves unimportant and defective by comparison. Perhaps explosions (of any kind) are always followed by implosions – and since everything is connected, everything goes down.

The Sun as a Model of the Human World

National Geographic Magazine – Solar Storms

This is the link for the text (which is excellent). To see the photos, click on the Photo Gallery on the upper left.

There is no way to adequately describe the Human Condition in words – and I have certainly tried. Words no longer have much of an impact.

But these images get the message across at the gut level. Human society is a blazing inferno of raw passions under the surface – while the surface (the outer shell) is totally dead. Except for the cracks where things are exploding.

Everyone is saying “Pay no attention to them! There is only one way to be: dead, like us – that way you cannot be hurt.”

Hate All, Kill All

For me, the pieces of the puzzle are falling into place; the puzzle being an understanding of how the world works. The picture they are forming may not make much sense to anyone else; and may even seem insane.

One major piece of the puzzle is Hatred, which is sometimes so strong in my life I can hardly stand it. It seems to be a message screaming at me, but the message never made much sense. What meaning could hatred have?

I has finally dawned on me that its meaning is crucial (note the similarity between crucial and the cross). Basic Christian theology is profound here, if perverse. The Romans hated the Jews, and destroyed the Jewish state. But Christianity ended up being a Roman religion – after a very complicated transition that most Christians don’t want to think about.

Another major piece of the puzzle is negative being, or the reversal of values. For people in this state, bad is good, stupid is wise, and hate is love. And there is no way they can detect this simple switch has happened.

The result is a state analogous to the Christian ascension into heaven where believers are born anew, and are forgiven of their sins. In its Protestant form, the results are more complicated, and produced our affluent world, where we live in a heaven on earth – and a hell on earth at the same time.

These people (and myself, when I am feeling like them) hate everything. And this feeling is an integral part of who they are, it is not optional, something that happens only part of the time, depending on the circumstances; it is a fundamental, constant attitude.

Another piece of the puzzle is unawareness, the opposite of awareness. These people are not aware of anything – but think they are aware of everything.

Beginning to get the picture? Like it?

For awhile I wondered how hatred could kill, but then I wondered how I could have wondered about anything so obvious. Hatred says “Drop dead!” And people who are hated do just that, when the message is universal (from everyone).

“How do they die?” you might ask. There is no simple answer to this question, it depends on the circumstances. But in many cases they simply fade into the woodwork, as defined here. This may seem like an innocuous form of being, but it is really becoming negative, a state where people can commit the worst atrocities – and think nothing of it.

However, other things can also happen. In response to hatred, some groups of people can use this to define themselves. I am sure, for example the Taliban feels this way. Our hatred of them is what defines them, and is the strongest weapon they have. In American history, our hatred of the British (which was a long time forming, and was never complete) defined what being an American was.

Another response to hatred is mental illness. If the person doing the hating is an authority figure (a parent, for example) this puts the child in a difficult situation. The result can be psychosomatic illness of many kinds, which are very common – but which are usually unacknowledged.

They are unaware – and are strongly opposed to being aware.

Destruction of the Self

Humans are the only beings that can have a self. Any child builds one naturally, and it is the greatest pleasure of any parent to watch this happen – and help it to happen. The same is true of society; any human society is built by its people – and it is their greatest pleasure to develop it and help it happen.

It used to be this way until recently, when the opposite process started happening. We started destroying our selves and our societies. And this process is now nearly complete.

This, as far as I am concerned, is a fact and I will not argue about it. Either you agree with me or you don’t – it makes no difference to me. I will proceed as though I were talking to myself, but you are welcome to listen in to this conversation.

My first reaction to this was shock – a shock I have never completely recovered from. Sometime early in my development I had the feeling that something was terribly wrong (my parents did not care for me) – but that I existed anyway. And I never gave up this insight.

In the work environment I continued to be shocked by how destructive it was. But somehow or other, I survived enough to leave and build a new life in Costa Rica.

In all of this, I observed that most people were not people, but something else I could not (and still cannot) comprehend. Whatever they are, they have no selves. These seem to have been abandoned in the rush to become something else.

What was this something else? Perhaps this question will never be answered. Whatever it is, it probably cannot be answered in a few words. But that is not important, all we have to agree on is that something has happened to us, and something catastrophic. We can put off the naming of it until later.

Our most important task now is to acknowledge that something bad has happened to us – something extremely bad. And not go on pretending that it hasn’t.

But to do this, we have to have a self to do the knowing with. Without that we are doomed.

Being Part of Something Big

This is one of the most powerful of our human obsessions. It probably showed up about the time we became civilized. Before that, we were content to live in small societies, and felt no need for something bigger.

The coming of civilization has never been studied very thoroughly, as far as I know. Perhaps one reason for this avoidance was the deeply embedded insanity that became part of our collective personality. An insanity that has only gotten worse as we became more advanced.

Living in Latin America, I can see this difference plainly. They feel no need to improve themselves, because their society is good enough already – and always has been, as far as they can see.

I can also see that America is moving in this direction also: the way things are is good enough and any attempt to improve them makes them uncomfortable.

In either case, the people are part of something bigger – a society that is changing or not changing.

What interests me now is when we became obsessed with being part of something really big - the beginning of the Modern World. This is another subject that has not been studied very well: what on earth got into us? Perhaps it was the idea of unlimited growth - a preposterous idea, but one still very much in fashion.

What actually happened was truly amazing: as unlimited growth became impossible, most of our lives became unconscious - and lost touch with reality! To put this another way: we became unaware.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 361 other followers